In a discovery that’s gripping the numismatic world and making headlines across the country. A rare Kennedy Half Dollar has emerged from the shadows of a decades-old safe deposit box — and its unearthing has set off a fierce auction feud, one now under FBI investigation.
An Unexpected Find in a Forgotten Vault
The drama began in early March when a woman in her 60s, only identified as “Marie R.” from Ohio, was sorting through her late father’s belongings. Among stacks of old paperwork and photos, she found a long-forgotten key labeled “Box 38B – National Bank Vault.”
What she discovered inside the safe deposit box stunned her. Nestled in a velvet pouch was a pristine Kennedy Half Dollar, untouched by time. At first glance, it seemed like an ordinary coin. But when shown to a local coin dealer, it turned out to be a highly unusual variety from 1964 — potentially one of only a handful known to exist with striking anomalies tied to early mint experimentation following President Kennedy’s assassination.
A Coin with a Mysterious Past
The coin bears all the standard hallmarks of the original 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar — the first year the coin was minted — but experts noticed subtle differences in the font, surface, and strike. These features raised speculation that it might be a prototype or a trial piece from the U.S. Mint, possibly never intended for public circulation.
Within days, news of the coin leaked to the wider collector community. Major auction houses began reaching out to Marie with offers, and one even scheduled the coin for a spring auction, estimating it could fetch between $200,000 to $500,000.
That’s when things took an unexpected turn.
Claims, Counterclaims, and an FBI Inquiry
Shortly after the auction listing went public, a claim was filed by an anonymous party asserting that the coin may have been part of a collection reported missing in a 1989 estate dispute involving a retired U.S. Mint employee. The claim included detailed documentation and photographs, some of which appear to match the newly discovered coin.
With questions swirling about rightful ownership, the auction was abruptly halted. The FBI was brought in to mediate and investigate, confirming that the coin is now in secure federal custody pending further review.
FBI spokesperson Karen Matheson confirmed in a press briefing, “We are conducting a thorough provenance investigation to ensure that all claims of ownership are reviewed fairly and lawfully. The case involves complex historical records and institutional access from over 30 years ago.”
Collectors React to the Auction Fallout
The numismatic community has been abuzz on online forums and social media, with many collectors speculating about the coin’s origin and rarity. Some believe it could be linked to a batch of experimental strikes made during a chaotic transitional period at the Mint. Others think it might be one of the rumored “backdoor” coins smuggled out by employees before stricter controls were implemented.
“Whatever the outcome, this coin is now part of American coin lore,” said historian and coin appraiser Charles Hendricks. “It’s a window into a moment in U.S. history when the Mint was racing to memorialize a fallen president — and perhaps making decisions that weren’t always properly documented.”
Also Read:- 1982 Lincoln penny Coin Have Government Mistake — And Now It’s Worth 5 Figures
What Happens Next?
As the investigation unfolds, the coin’s future remains uncertain. If rightful ownership can’t be conclusively established, it’s possible the U.S. government could lay claim to it under federal laws regarding Mint property. Alternatively, if Marie R. is proven to be the legal owner, the coin could reappear on the auction block later this year — likely with even greater interest and a much higher starting bid.
For now, collectors and curious Americans alike are watching closely as the mystery of this Kennedy Half Dollar plays out. It’s a rare story where history, intrigue, and a single coin intersect — with the FBI watching over it all.
